
Britt Watty, a Director of Fleet Strategy at EMKAY, has spent years helping companies dig underneath fleet costs, and she keeps finding the same thing. The costliest problems in most fleets trace back to decisions about vehicle selection, replacement timing, funding and reimbursement that were made years ago and never reopened.
“Meanwhile, the business evolves,” she says. “That’s where costs start to creep in.”
We sat down with Britt to talk through the strategic questions fleet leaders should be asking, and the data that should be answering them.
How fleets drift off course
Few fleets are designed from scratch. Most grow alongside the company, one decision at a time.
“In many cases, the fleet evolved organically as the company grew,” Britt says. “Vehicles were added over time, acquired through acquisitions or mergers with other companies, or sourced based on availability and relationships with local dealerships. Over time, those decisions simply became the status quo.”
The biggest opportunities, in her experience, are “found by asking bigger questions: Are we replacing vehicles at the right time? Do we have the right vehicles for the job? Is our funding strategy still appropriate?”
“They’re strategy questions,” she says. “And that’s where the greatest opportunities for improvement are usually found.”
A paid-off vehicle still has a monthly bill
One of the most persistent misconceptions Britt encounters is the belief that a vehicle stops costing money once it’s paid off.
“In reality, the vehicle continues to generate costs every day through maintenance, fuel, downtime, and declining resale value,” she says.
When organizations anchor on what they paid for a vehicle years ago, they lose sight of what it costs to run today. “That’s where the bigger strategic opportunities are usually hiding,” Britt says.
The pattern often starts in the repair shop. “One of the most common traps I see is a company investing in a major repair, such as a transmission or engine replacement, and then feeling obligated to keep the vehicle longer to ‘recoup’ that expense,” she explains. “That’s often where the cycle begins.”
Finding the replacement window
“Every vehicle has an optimal replacement window, where resale value remains strong and operating costs are still relatively predictable,” Britt says. “As vehicles age, maintenance costs increase, downtime becomes more frequent, and resale value continues to decline.”
The right cycle differs from fleet to fleet. “There is a ‘right’ replacement cycle for every fleet, but it varies based on factors such as vehicle type, utilization, mileage, operating environment, and application,” she says. “The decision should be driven by the data.”
That means tracking maintenance costs, fuel economy, downtime and resale value over time and watching for the point where the trends converge. “When those factors begin to overlap, you’ve typically reached the optimal replacement point,” she says.
“The goal is to maximize the total value you receive from the asset while minimizing the cost to operate it.”
— Britt Watty, Director of Fleet Strategy, EMKAY
Hitting that window pays off twice. The outgoing vehicle still holds equity, and the incoming vehicle resets operating costs to a lower baseline.
“Organizations that manage replacement well use the equity they’ve built in the vehicle to offset the cost of the replacement unit,” Britt says. “The result is lower operating costs, fewer surprises, and a more predictable fleet budget. They’re following a strategy.”
Start with the job
When choosing vehicles, Britt’s starting point is direct. “The first question is simple: What is the job of the vehicle? Is it hauling cargo? Carrying equipment? Transporting employees? Operating on paved roads, job sites, or off-road environments?”
From there, companies can determine the right vehicle class, payload, storage, towing capacity and fuel type. Too many fleets default to purchase price or habit. Britt evaluates vehicles through total cost of ownership, which accounts for fuel, maintenance, depreciation, downtime, incentives and expected resale value across the vehicle’s life.
“The cheapest way to acquire a vehicle isn’t always the cheapest way to operate a fleet.”
— Britt Watty
Two examples from her work show what a better fit can do. Engineering and surveying firms she worked with were seeing excessive tire wear and preventable incidents because their vehicles weren’t suited to the terrain they drove every day. “By moving into vehicles and tire packages better matched to those conditions, they reduced tire replacement costs, improved reliability, and enhanced driver safety,” she says.
She has also helped fleets move from full-size pickups and SUVs into compact pickups and crossovers. “In many cases, employees weren’t towing, hauling heavy payloads, or operating in environments that required a larger vehicle,” she says. “Moving into a right-typed vehicle reduced acquisition costs, improved fuel economy, and lowered the overall cost of operating the fleet.”
The common thread is a fleet that stood still while the business moved. “When you periodically re-evaluate vehicle selection against actual business needs, it can have a meaningful impact on both costs and operational effectiveness,” Britt says.
When a company vehicle beats reimbursement
For employees driving their own vehicles for work, Britt offers a benchmark.
“While every situation is different, a common rule of thumb is that once an employee is driving more than 12,000 business miles per year, a company-provided vehicle often becomes the more economical option,” she says. “However, mileage is only one factor.”
A company vehicle gives the organization more control over what employees drive for business, reduces liability exposure, presents a consistent company image and can improve the employee experience. Britt recommends comparing the full cost of reimbursement against the full cost of providing a vehicle, then weighing the benefits a spreadsheet won’t capture.
“Frequently, the decision is as much about control, consistency, and risk management as it is about cost,” she says.
Funding decisions reach the balance sheet
“Funding decisions impact far more than how a vehicle is acquired,” Britt says. “They can affect cash flow, borrowing capacity, financial ratios, and a company’s ability to invest capital elsewhere in the business.”
Buying outright can make sense for organizations with ample cash reserves, though it requires a significant upfront investment. Britt has also noticed a pattern. “I’ve rarely met a company that pays cash for their vehicles and still maintains a disciplined replacement plan,” she says. “More often, the vehicles remain in service longer than intended because they’re ‘paid off.’”
Leasing spreads costs over time and builds a more predictable replacement cycle into the program. It also keeps capital out of depreciating assets so it can go to work elsewhere in the business.
Finance teams sometimes evaluate a funding structure by its monthly payment alone. Britt encourages them to look at how that structure plays out across the vehicle’s entire lifecycle, including depreciation schedules that match expected usage and mileage. A well-structured lease should leave vehicles in an equity position at replacement time, so that equity can offset the cost of the next unit.
“The most effective funding strategies align accounting, cash flow, and replacement planning,” she says. Her advice to finance leaders is to ask a broader question: “What is the most effective use of our capital, and how does our fleet funding strategy support the company’s overall financial goals?”
Where fleets leak money
Asked where fleets lose money without realizing it, Britt’s short answer was “all of the above.” Each cost category has its own blind spot.
- Fuel. Small gains compound. “If you have a fleet of 100 vehicles and improve fuel economy by even 2 MPG across the board, the savings can be substantial over thousands of miles driven each year,” she says.
- Maintenance. Repair approvals tend to happen one at a time, under pressure. “A vehicle breaks down, the company needs it back on the road, so they approve the repair. Then a few months later, something else fails,” Britt says. “That’s how money pits begin.”
- Downtime. “For a service fleet, downtime is often one of the most expensive and least measured costs,” she says. “Every day a technician is waiting on a vehicle repair is a day they’re not serving customers.” She suggests asking two questions about any repair: what is it costing, and what is the lost productivity on top of that?
- Resale. “Resale value may be the most overlooked area of all,” Britt says. Many organizations assume an older, higher-mileage vehicle isn’t worth much, yet timing has a major effect on resale proceeds. Selling before maintenance costs accelerate preserves equity that can fund the next vehicle.
The biggest savings come from seeing how these four categories interact. Together, they shape total cost of ownership, so Britt encourages fleets to look at the entire lifecycle of the vehicle along with each line item.
In her words: a Q&A with Britt Watty
We closed the conversation with three questions every fleet manager should be asking. Britt’s answers have been lightly edited for length.
What metrics should every fleet manager be benchmarking against?
“Every fleet should be tracking and benchmarking the core drivers of total cost of ownership: fuel cost, maintenance expense, downtime, accident frequency, utilization, resale performance and replacement cycle performance. More importantly, those metrics should be reviewed year over year to identify trends.
“It’s also important to understand when operating costs begin to accelerate as vehicles age. Most vehicles reach a point where maintenance expenses, downtime, and fuel inefficiency increase significantly. Identifying those trends helps determine the optimal replacement cycle.
“Knowing your own numbers is important, but understanding how they compare to your peers provides the context needed to identify opportunities for improvement.”
If a fleet manager could make one strategic change this year, what should it be?
“With fuel costs unpredictable, I’d focus on right-sizing and right-typing the fleet.
“Right-sizing means evaluating whether you have the right number of vehicles. Are there underutilized assets? Too many spare units? If a vehicle isn’t needed, consider removing it from service and capturing the equity that’s tied up in it.
“Right-typing means making sure employees are driving the right vehicle for the job. Do you need a diesel engine truck, or would a gas engine suffice? Does the application require a half-ton pickup, or could a compact pickup or small SUV handle the work just as effectively?
“I’m currently helping several fleets evaluate compact pickups in place of traditional half-ton trucks. When the application allows it, moving into a smaller, more fuel-efficient vehicle can reduce acquisition costs, fuel spend, and overall operating costs without sacrificing productivity. In my experience, some of the biggest fleet savings opportunities come from ensuring you have the right vehicles performing the right work.”
What separates a strategic fleet from a reactive one?
“The biggest difference between strategic fleets and reactive fleets is data. Many organizations have information spread across multiple systems, spreadsheets, fuel providers, maintenance vendors, telematics platforms, and accounting systems. As a result, they’re making decisions based on incomplete information.
“In 2026, there’s really no reason fleet managers should have to log into multiple systems to understand what’s happening in their fleet. Technology should simplify decision-making.
“At the end of the day, the best fleets are the ones using data to make proactive decisions before small issues become expensive problems.”
Put your fleet data to work
EMKAY brings fuel, maintenance, telematics and lifecycle data into a single source of truth, giving fleet leaders clear visibility into utilization, downtime, costs and replacement opportunities. Our fleet strategy team, including Britt, helps clients benchmark against similar fleets, optimize replacement cycles, evaluate reimbursement against company vehicles and right-size their fleets.
Want to see how your fleet compares? Call EMKAY at 630.250.7400 or email info@emkay.com.
Does Toyota Make a Cargo Van? What Fleet Managers Should Know About Toyota Commercial Vehicles
Search for a Toyota cargo van and you'll find dealer pages, used listings, and forum threads asking the same question. Fleet managers ask for good reason; toyota has a long record for reliability and resale value, and many fleets already run Toyota pickups, sedans, and SUVs. Adding a van from the same brand would keep service, parts, and purchasing simpler.
What to Do After a Collision in a Work Vehicle
A collision involving a company vehicle typically happens when a driver is mid-route, mid-shift, or mid-delivery, and the instinct in that first minute is to sort out blame or start worrying about the truck. That instinct is backwards. The first minute belongs to safety and nothing else, and everything that happens afterward — the claim, the repair timeline, the liability conversation — goes smoother.